Identifying Ancient Horseshoes—Wavy-Edged Horseshoes

Most of my oldest horseshoes were bought from metal-detectorists from Great Britain. I also have a few from the Ukraine, but I can’t find any reliable source of research that is written in english to tell for certain how old the Ukrainian ones are. I will include photos of my Ukrainian shoes as examples here, dating them as if they were from Great Britain.

The resources that I use are

  1. The Museum of London website, as they have excellent photos of their horseshoe collection available online, listing their estimated dates.
  2. This book:

3. This book:

Wavy Rimmed horseshoes have a wavy outer rim. The waviness occurs from when the nail holes were punched into the shoe, so that the outside rim widens around where the nails are. Here is an example:

This shoe is actually from Kievan Rus in the Ukraine. The finder says it may have been from the Tartars but we really don’t know. It is a great example of the waviness around the nail holes, though. If dated using the Great Britain books it might be from the 10th-11th century.
Another view of the above shoe. It’s so small!
The back.

Older wavy rimmed shoes usually have longer, oval shaped depressions around the nail holes. Nails with T-shaped heads and nails that have a fiddle head appearance were widely used, and aided in traction. The oval depressions around the nail holes helped the nail heads to stay in place and helped keep the shoe on.

There are two main types of wavy rimmed shoe, according to the shapes of the nail holes.

One has round nail holes, and was more popular during the 10th-11th century, and the other has more rectangular nail holes and was more popular around the 11th-12th century.

When there is a lot of corrosion it can be hard sometimes to tell the shapes of the holes, but i will do my best with what shoes i have.

This shoe is a great example of one having rectangular nail holes. The long countersinkings around the holes are also clearly visible. This one is probably from the 11th-12th century (1001-1200 AD).
The back view
I believe the nail holes on this shoe would be considered round. It might be from around the 10th-11th century (901-1100AD).
The back.
This one is hard to tell. I know it’s an older shoe because of the long rectangular countersinking around the nail holes.
When we look at the back, it looks like the nail holes might be round, so it might be from the 10-11th century.
This shoe has longer holes, so my guess is that they are rectangular and possibly from the 11th-12th century.
The back.
This shoe is unusual in that it has a nail in the toe. Shoes usually don’t have nails in the toe because that area gets the most wear. It has the characteristic long nail holes of an older shoe.
The back shows that the holes are small and probably round, dating it to possibly the 10th-11th century.
This shoe is from the Ukraine. It has longer countersinkings around the nail holes and a wavy outer edge. Are the nail holes round or rectangular? It’s hard to tell. It could be from between the 10-12th century.
Here is another from the Ukraine, in excellent shape and cleaned professionally. It has a wavy outer edge and long countersinkings. I think maybe rectangular nail holes? Possibly 11-12th century.
This shoe is hard to see the nailholes in the photo, but i tried to catch the right light to show the long countersinkings.
A back view of the same shoe. The nails are more round.
Also of interest on this shoe, note the almost fiddle-head shaped nail head. This was a common feature of the very old shoes and served to add traction, as they stuck out a bit at the bottom of the shoe.
This shoe has 8 nail holes that go all along the shoe, including the toe region. It’s hard to tell what shape the nail holes are, as it has a little bit of stubborn corrosion that I haven’t been able to remove.
A back view of the same shoe.
This shoe, I felt, was too delicate to clean properly, at least with the vinegar method that I often use. I kept it in the original condition that it came to me.
The back side. I think that this shoe might also be one of the more ancient ones that I possess, but it is hard to tell exactly what is under all of the rust and corrosion. I believe it is at least a guildhall shoe due to the angular inner edge, but the enlarged nail holes on the one side could indicate an older shoe. They could also just be enlarged from being more corroded there. It’s hard to tell without cleaning it properly. Note the fragile state of its more open holes—an area that bends easily and must be handled with care due to the cracks. I may one day strengthen the damage with an epoxy of some sort so that the piece doesn’t break off and get lost. This shoe is one that I would like to use electrolysis on if I ever get a setup.

Unless there is a recorded history of the shoe, or it was found in a specific location surrounded by specific items from a specific time frame, the ages of most shoes can only be estimated based on what was common for the area it was found in. I try to keep cautious when purchasing shoes that are supposed to be old, as an experienced blacksmith can recreate an old-fashioned shoe. Most of the ancient ones that i have purchased are from reputable sources and i have had to clean off enough layers of rust and corrosion to where I feel confident that they have been in the ground for a few hundred years (lol).

Horseshoe collecting—Shoes with Provenance

While I never did get good marks in History classes (I have to stop and think sometimes to remember important dates in my OWN life, much less others!), I do love seeing and learning about historical artifacts. As a child (and even as a teen) I always wanted to be an archaeologist, digging and discovering.

What I really love is when I find a horseshoe (or other antique) that comes with a story. It isn’t often that you find the history of a lowly horseshoe, but sometimes you will, and sometimes all you have to do is ask, as some sellers don’t think it’s important to say where they dug the shoe up, or how their grandfather was an award winning farrier back in the day and this was one last shoe he kept hanging above his garage door.

Isn’t it beautiful? The curved toe bar and angled heel caulks?
This shoe, and several others that I ended up purchasing, was found by the seller’s uncle when he was younger. He was fascinated with old logging camps in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, and spent much of his time searching them out through the woods. He picked up several old horseshoes in such locations, and nailed them all along his fences. Their age and condition testify to them probably being worn by the horses of lumberjacks to haul wood in the 1800’s-early 1900’s. Notice the extra bars at heel and toe, called caulkins, that were added for traction. I see this a LOT in old shoes in Michigan, where farming and logging were commonplace in our history.
This shoe was found along an old stagecoach road in California.
This enormous draft horse shoe was found near the old Smithy in Achafoila on the Aisle of Luing in Scotland. For some reason I can imagine a big old workhorse named Betty wearing it.
This shoe was found along with a few others near an old gold mine.
This mule shoe was found around Fort Custer, in Montana. Was it from the Indian Wars?
This shoe was found metal detecting along the Oregon Trail in Wyoming. It has so much wear to it!
This shoe was from a mule used in tours at the Grand Canyon.
This solid copper shoe was from a pit pony in a coal mine in Wales.

You may be wondering why all of my shoes have tags on them. I tag and number each individual shoe, and write a description of it on an index card so i know where i bought it, everything I know about it, how much I paid, etc. I also draw myself a little picture of it so it is easily recognized when I go to find the individual shoe. I keep the cards organized in a card index.

How I record important information about each shoe. The number on the card matches the numbered tag on the shoe.

I hope that with careful record keeping I can safeguard the history of each of my shoes. Unfortunately I didn’t do these things when I first started collecting as a child, but I remember a few details about my favorite shoes.

I have many, many more shoes in my collection (at the moment of writing this I own over 330 shoes). Record keeping helps keep their information organized and readily available. Now if I can just find an easy way to keep the shoes themselves organized 🤔.

Identifying Ancient Horseshoes—Guildhall Horseshoes of ancient Britain

I have been collecting horseshoes all of my life, and have a decent amount from Great Britain. The shoes from this area are much easier to date for me, as there is more written documentation about shoeing practices, much more research has been done, and I have a couple of excellent research books on them. One of the books that I have found is ‘Old Horseshoes’ by Ivan G. Sparks.

This is a great book! It is small but filled with good information!

Another excellent book is ‘The Medieval Horse and its Equipment’ by the Museum of London. The Editor, John Clark, categorizes the different types of shoes a little differently than Ivan Sparks, but gives them roughly the same time periods. Today I am going to focus on the Guildhall shoe (according to Ivan Sparks) or Type 4 (according to John Clark).

Another great source is the Museum of London’s website. They have many photos of medieval shoes and their approximate dates. I often quiz myself on trying to date them according to what I have read in books, and use their shoes to help identify some of my own more puzzling examples.

The Guildhall shoe, according to Ivan Sparks, has a rounded outer edge and an arched inner edge. This shoe is a good example:

These shoes gained popularity around 1350 AD to accommodate the larger breeds of horses being imported to the area. They gradually were replaced by keyhole shoes by around the 1600’s. According to John Clark, they were often found in the 14-15th centuries (around 13-1400’s).

They tended to have just one calkin, but they could have two as well. They sometimes had 6 nailholes, and sometimes 7 (3 on one side and 4 on the other). The shoes are fairly small, maybe about the size of today’s average riding horse. Certainly not as large as today’s drafts!

Below are some samples from my own collection. They have been cleaned so I can more easily identify the number of nailholes, special features, etc.

As you can see, most of these shoes are pretty small.
This shoe is quite thick and heavy! I left a rusty patina on it, but they are all coated with clear Rustoleum paint to stop further rusting
Another photo of the shoe above, to show just how thick it is!
I believe this is a later shoe, possibly getting a little closer to the keyhole variety. It is a bit larger than the others, and the squared off heel on the left seems to remind me of the keyhole heels.
This shoe has a great angular inner profile! It is a bit larger than the others. It also has a lot of damage to the right side.

Wouldn’t it be wonderful if these shoes could talk? To hear all of the stories of the horses that once were, what their lives were like, and all that occurred in the hundreds of years that these shoes were under ground!